Episode 68 · 9 January 2022 · 22:53

Thinking Positive Will Not Make You Happy – This Will!

Can you actually control your thoughts? No, and being told to think positive is exactly why so many people feel they are failing at it.

Subject: Inner Peace Foundations

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Stillness in the Storms · Episode 68

Can you actually control your thoughts? No, and being told to think positive is exactly why so many people feel they are failing at it.

I hit rock bottom in a shopping centre and a security guard stepped down off his platform and walked over to me. Everything left me at once. For the first time in my life I could only think negatively, and it hurt so much I had no idea what to do with it. You do not have exclusive access to your own mind. It hands you thoughts the way a child hands you a drawing. What you do with it is the only part that was ever yours.

One thing to try: When the next thought arrives, do not judge it. Just decide whether you are getting on it.

In this episode

  • (0:10) So you think you can control your thoughts
  • (1:26) The man who broke his neck and stayed relentlessly positive
  • (3:00) The shopping centre, and the security guard who came over
  • (4:28) The moment every thought left me
  • (6:03) Only being able to think negatively, for the first time ever
  • (8:55) You do not have exclusive access to your own mind
  • (11:28) The child bringing you a drawing, and what you say next
  • (17:02) Where the gold actually is

The companion talk episode: 2 Words You Should Stop Using AND What to Use Instead

Support the podcast and join the Weekly Calm: stevenwebb.uk

Thank you for listening.

Steven

The question this answers

Can you actually control your thoughts?

No. And being told to think positive is exactly why so many people feel they are failing at something that was never available.

The heart of it

  • You do not have exclusive access to your own mind. It hands you thoughts and you did not order them.
  • What you can train is which ones you get on. That is the whole lever.
  • Where you put your attention decides what you get more of.

I used to be the person who told everybody to look on the bright side. Broke his neck, always cheerful, always flipping it around. That was me, right up until it stopped working.

I was forty. My partner had ended things a fortnight earlier with no warning at all. For about two weeks after that I felt nothing whatsoever. No good, no bad, no drive. As though my ego had said, right, I have carried you this far, you are on your own now. If my carers had not got me out of bed I do not think I would have moved.

Then my wheelchair broke down in the doorway of Boots. A wire had caught round the wheel and that was that. Grown man, forty years old, sitting there sobbing, no money to fix it and nobody to ring.

The security guard came down off his platform, walked over, and squeezed my shoulder.

And that is when the thoughts came back, all of them, all bad. For the first time in my life I could only think negatively, and it hurt more than I knew was possible.

What eventually shifted it was a small book, As A Man Thinketh, and one idea in it. I have thoughts. I am not those thoughts.

So I sat and watched them, and worked out the thing this episode is about. Ask yourself what your next thought will be. Your mind goes blank, because you were never the one choosing.

Here is the picture I use. A child runs up and hands you an ice cream, and it is banana. You cannot turn it into mint chocolate chip by objecting. What you can do, over time, is teach the child which one gets a warm reception.

Your subconscious is that child. It does not know good from bad. It knows which thought got a reaction, and it brings you more of those. Mine brought me pictures of my ex with somebody else, over and over, because those pictures produced the strongest feeling in the house.

One small thing to try

When the next thought arrives, do not judge it. Just decide whether you are getting on it.

Is this useful. Is this relevant right now. That question takes a second and it is the entire practice.

Then do the other half. When something is lost, name what is still here. Edith Eger arrived at Auschwitz and lost both parents on the first day, and what she held onto was that she still had her sister. Where you put your attention is the whole difference between being flattened and not.

Questions people ask

So positive thinking is nonsense?

It is not sustainable as a policy. You will have met somebody who is all light and love and then bumped into them three weeks later in pieces. Going through that phase is probably necessary. Staying in it is not.

Are negative thoughts bad?

No, they are protective. Without a negative bias most of us would not reach ten. The trouble is not the thought, it is the habit of following it long after it has stopped being useful.

Do you manage this all the time?

No. I go with the habit about ninety nine percent of the day, and I say so in the episode. It is the other one percent that has changed things.

Read along

The transcript

It follows the audio. Press any line to jump there.

overthinking · mindfulness · happiness · acceptance

Read the transcript

So you think you can control your thoughts.

It's a nice idea, isn't it? And everybody tells you to think positive or to stop to think a certain

way. Stop thinking negative.

What a nice thought if it was just able to be done. You know, just like putting the telephone on

mute.

Wouldn't that be lovely?

But I'm going to give you some bad news. You're not in control of your thoughts. In any way. Now

then, let me explain.

Welcome to Stillness in the Storms, the podcast by Steven Webb, your host, yours truly. And it's a podcast that

just helps you to see life a little bit different. And hopefully, in the meantime, get a little bit of

inner peace and calm from the result. So I want to talk about our thoughts and how the mind works.

But first of all, I want to tell you a little story.

I was the person that, you know, you imagine this person that had been through difficulty.

And he broke his neck and he was always happy and he was always like this happy-go-lucky, always seemed to

be on the positive side, always thought positively. And whenever anybody would be negative around him he's oh just think

positive, be happy. You know, you've just got to look on the bright side, flip it around, turn it around.

I was that person. And then I hit my rock bottom.

And it happened a few times, but when I really hit my rock bottom... I don't know if any of

you know the story, but I'm going to tell you, just in case you haven't heard it um I was

I found myself single. My partner just left and I had no money. Everything was going wrong and

my my life was completely snowballing.

I was in the doorway to Boots and my chair just broke down. It's like a supermarket for well-being stuff.

A wire had caught around the wheel and that was it grinded to a halt I sat there and I

just burst out in tears. Here was a 40 year old fully grown man, crying. And it

wasn't just tears I could hold back. I was literally bawling my eyes out. I'd had enough. You know, if

anything could go wrong in my life, it was then and it had. And it all just, I don't know,

just, it was the perfect storm. Everything. And I was in a wheelchair that I couldn't, I had no money

to repair. I was single I My credit cards were to the hill. I felt lonely. I felt just, oh,

that was it. My whole life was, my whole life sucked. And the security guard that was just stood on

a little platform a few feet away, stepped down off the platform, walked over to me and just squeezed my

shoulder. And

it was that quiet moment it's like I

gotta sort my life out, but I just didn't know how to. And it was at that point, I think,

that my mind just started coming back with all the thoughts of everything that was going wrong.

Just a couple of weeks before that, somebody who I was dating for about 18 months had finished with me

completely out of the blue. I had no idea it was going to happen. I thought the relationship was perfect

you know I thought I was the best boyfriend. I took her an Indian a few days before. You know,

what kind of what kind of boyfriend does that? I was the ultimate boyfriend. I had no idea, you know

it wasn't it wasn't all sunshine and roses. But I was this positive thing, see all the good side and

all that all the time. And then she let me know that she wanted to move on. And when

I say move on, not to find somebody else, but just at the time I thought she was good. I

thought she was gonna see somebody else. But that was just hurting. That was just painful thoughts. But she left.

She let me know and uh and come over and picked up her stuff. And that was the moment where

all my thoughts left me. All my soul left me. It's like my ego had said, do you know what

Stevie? I've done everything for you all your life. You're on your own now mate. And I just felt nothing

for about two weeks. I was in a... I felt no good. I felt no bad bad I

didn't have no drive. I had no, I had nothing. There was nothing there. And if I didn't have carers

to get me out of bed and I

I don't know what I'd have done. I think I'd just got in bed and done nothing. And I just,

that was it. I had no thoughts and it was really, really weird. It was like as if I was

on my own, but I didn't exist. And

I I think they call it the dark night of the soul when, you know, it's just I've had enough

I'm done. I'm done with you, Stevie. But there's no Stevie. Just done. That's it. And then a

couple of weeks later when I started to get back on my feet metaphorically, that's when everything really went wrong.

My wheelchair broke and my credit cards were to the hill. And sat in that doorway bawling my eyes out.

I had to get a friend to come down and help me into the van and Took me home. And

that was when all of my thoughts started to come back in my mind. All the thoughts of, ah, they're

having an affair, they're doing this, they're seeing that. You know, they're doing all the things that I wanted to

do. But it wasn't only that. Everybody was having a better life than me.

And suddenly for the first time in my life, really in a deep way, I found myself only thinking negative.

Every

thought was bad and it was so painful I had no idea how painful it could get but it was

just horribly painful. I couldn't sleep, I couldn't eat, I felt sick all the time

and all I wanted to do was shut my mind off and like I said for the first time I

really experienced what it was like to not be that positive person and

then after a while and I was drinking to get myself to sleep and things like that. But after a

while, I started reading a book and it was As A Man think of by James Allen. And it gave

me the thoughts that I am what I think.

And it separated me from my thoughts. So I recognise that there's thoughts. Ah, there's a thought. And I could

be aware of that thought. So if you think of, I don't know, of a flying pink elephant right now,

you're a person sat there. Thinking of and been aware of that thought.

Okay, bear with me a minute because this will have meaning in a minute. You know, when you first introduce

this, you're like, what? Okay, but just bear with me for a minute. Open your mind and just enjoy the

journey just for the minute. So so we have thoughts. I have thoughts. I started watching those thoughts in

meditation and every book told me I could meditate or I should meditate. That was the answer. I disagree with

every book because like no, I can't meditate. I think too much. But after 10 books, every single one of

them telling you you ought to meditate or give it a try. At some point you gotta go okay, these

are all people that have turned their lives around and they you know they're telling me to do something. And

here I am, my life's a mess, telling them I cannot do the one thing they're telling me to do.

So at some point you got to listen to someone that's already sorted their shit out. So

I started meditating, or I just started sitting there and observing my thoughts. And I realised one thing. I wasn't

in control of my thoughts.

Now think about that for a minute. If you're in control of your thoughts,

what is your next thought?

Come on, you can tell me, you can just tell me now. What is your next thought going to be?

The mind goes blank. Because

you're not in control of what your next thoughts are. They come subconsciously out of your mind. Your mind, you

haven't got exclusive access to it. I know it's crazy, but you haven't you know It's in your head, it

is you, but you don't have exclusive access. You don't have the ability to tune into that back door

and choose what's in there you know The sounds that go in. There's not a lot you can do about

it. Your ears are open all the time.

So the thoughts that come up, just like sounds that come up, they're there all the time. You you cannot

choose.

So now you're thinking, okay, brilliant. So now I can never think positive. I can never change my life because

I'm not in control of my thoughts. What am I in control of?

Good question and And that's the wise question. What am I in control of? Well, you're in control of what

you do with the thoughts.

That's like eating a donut. Now then, if you've got, if you're told you have to eat that donut, you

don't have any choice of where it goes on the body. We don't even choose where a donut goes on

our body. Think about that for a moment. Okay, this is a terrible analogy. I don't know even know why

I went to this analogy. But you'll get the point that we're not in control. Oh, you know me. You've

listening to this podcast long enough I go on enough tangents. Forget the donut. Forget that analogy. But

you are not in control. When a thought arises, it's already there. You can't do anything about it. It's like

a child running up to you and giving you an ice cream. This is a bare analogy. A child runs

up to you and says, here's an ice cream. Well, you've got the ice cream then. What we want to

do is we want to change the ice cream into something different because we don't like it. Perhaps he gives

us a banana ice cream. Who has banana ice cream? You do know.

So he walks up with banana ice cream and you're like, you don't want the banana ice cream. So we

jump up and down we get teasy and someone comes and tells us, well, just change the ice cream. You

cannot just change the ice cream because it's already there. It's present. It's already formed. But what we can do

is we can help the child understand that we don't like banana ice cream and to help the child by,

well, I'm not so keen on that one, so I'll put it in the bin. When

you've got a mint chocolate chip ice cream, bring that one to me. And then the child will go, oh,

really? You like messed up my game. The next time it'll bring a chocolate chip one. And you go, thank

you. That's brilliant. That's amazing. And then the child's like, ah, that's the response I wanted. Your subconscious

mind is like that child. It's giving you thoughts. It's giving you all kinds of thoughts. They're not good nor

bad. They're just thoughts. It's what we do. It's how we determine what those thoughts are. So

if we go, oh, that's a bad one, we tend to focus on it. If we go, that's a good

one, we tend to not really give much weight to it so The subconscious mind does not know what thoughts

to give you. So it's literally the mind thinks shit up all the time.

All the time. It just does it. It just drives down the road and thinks, what would you do if

you drew it drove over the wall? What do you do if you run into those people? What do you

do if you ended up pouring that drink on your head? Now the mind's just thinking of scenarios to protect

you. The mind's just, you know, and you know the good ones when you're sitting there and someone quite sexy

is in the room and you go, wouldn't mind. Might not be appropriate,

but we've all done it. Doesn't mean to say we have to act upon it and do anything with it,

but we've all done it. And then we try to get rid of that thought as well. So the mind

just thinks of thoughts up all the time. It's just what it does. But

we actively know whether or not to get on them or not now when you're driving down the road it

comes up with a thought of doing something in the car that is clearly going to endanger lives, we go,

no, I'm not going to get on that thought and I'm not going to do it.

But why do we get on these thoughts that are not necessarily damaging right then, but they are damaging over

time? Thoughts of when I found myself single and rock bottom. I thought that my ex was with

someone in an intimate position at that time. And that would hurt like hell. So why did I focus on

it so much but it gave me a deep feeling. Now, my subconscious mind doesn't mind what the feeding is

It just cares that it gave you a deep feeling. Just the same as the child. Doesn't matter whether the

attention is good or bad. It still wants attention.

So now it's starting to build a picture now of you're not in control of the thoughts, but you're in

control of which thoughts you get on. So

that's how you can turn your mind around to be more positive or to be more healthier. Because I don't

like the positive and negative, the good and bad. I don't think that helps because a negative thought doesn't necessarily

mean it's bad. It just means it's trying to protect you. We need negative thoughts. And I've done a podcast

about that, and I will link to it below in the show notes. You know, a negative bias is a

good thing. If we didn't have a negative bias, most of us would end up killing ourselves by the time

we're 10. And for one, I would have done dumb ass things if my mind wasn't coming up with scenarios

saying, don't do that. You

know, we have to almost think of the bad in order to prevent us doing it. Unfortunately, the subconscious mind

doesn't look at good or bad as good or bad. It just looks at it as a habit. So what

is a healthy mind? How do we replace this? Think positive, which doesn't work for very long either because you

think of all these people that think positive and happy and oh, it's all great. Life's just a bowl of

wonderful love and fun. You know, we all know these people and I've tried to be them. It

all comes crashing down about every three weeks and two days.

You bump into them on the street. How's it going? Oh, no, you wouldn't believe what's just happened. Well, last

week, you were like the bundle of love and all the trees were, you know, and

trust me, I'm not knocking. I'm like, I think that I think this is a brilliant segment to growing

up. I think it's we have to go through that realisation in order to realise that that's not sustainable. All

humans are doing these things all the time. We realise that it's not 100% healthy so

But we have to try it. We have to do it. So what is a healthy mind? What would a

healthy mind look like? What would a healthy mind do? Well, the healthy mind would, it's slow enough it's going

It's going at the right pace. And this is through meditation and mindfulness that a thought arises

and it can be aware of the thought instead of just becoming the thought. So instead of having a thought

and just going with a habitable response that you've always done, you've got that little gap.

So a thought happens and you can go, hmm, is this a productive healthy thought? Or is this an

irrelevant thought? Is this a helpful thought

um Is this something that is not is really quite helpful, although it's negative, but it's not relevant to this

moment. So you can become aware of what the thought is and you can make a wise choice what to

do with the thought.

And that's where the wisdom is that this is where This is where the gold is. This is where the

enlightenment enlightenment is. And this is where my life is no better now, really, than when I was at my

rock bottom. It might seem like it is. My finances are about the same. I'm still single

um You

know, I still spend as much time alone um okay

I'm mayor of truer which is pretty awesome. But that comes with more pressures I said again so That comes

with more pressures. I've almost got more problems now than what I had then.

So going back to our thoughts. So they arise. Wisdom. Enlightenment. Healthy.

What is the thought? Do we have to go over it or not? And you slowly train the subconscious mind

what you want to think about. So you slowly become not so much a positive thinker, not so much a

negative thinker or um you Well we do this anyway. All of our lives we're teaching the subconscious mind what

to do. The only thing is you're doing it consciously rather than subconsciously. Your mind has always been learning what

you want to think about. Hence the law of attraction. When you think about debt, you have more debt. When

you think about being a victim, you're more of a victim. When you think about positive things, you become more

positive. So

what you can do when you have, say, a gratitude of something When you lose something, instead of just going

down that oh I've lost it. I can't believe I got nothing left and they've left me and I've just

lost my Louis

baton um bag or whatever whatever it is you lost. And you think it's the end of the world. You

can go, wait a minute. That's just a thought. Yes, I've lost that, but I've still got this, this and

this. So you can actively think that little gap. You can choose what to do with the

thought.

That's it. That's the answer. And you can literally, and I'm reading a book at the moment called The Choice

by Edith Egger um She was a young girl and she went to Auschwitz and on the day she got

there, she lost both parents. And it was really the almost awful of circumstances. And at

that point, she realised that she still had her sister. So instead of thinking, I've lost this and

this, I've lost my home and all that, I've still got my sister. And she was able to, she said

the phrase, it's what you focus your attention on. So if you focus your attention on what you lost or

focus your attention on what you still have. There's the answer.

That's the answer to feeling miserable or not. That's the answer to being a victim or not.

It's where you focus your attention on. So a thought comes up.

What do you want to do with it? Do you want to dump it in the bin? Do you want

to go with it? Do you want to grow it? Do you want to... So doing it consciously. But don't

try to change the thought. And this is the point. Going right back to the beginning of the podcast, I

said you're not in control of the thoughts. And you're not. You're not in control of the flavor ice cream

that that child brings you because you've subconsciously trained the child to bring you a certain ice cream. Now you're

going to consciously train the child, train the child as a tongue twister, to bring you the

ice cream you want.

Okay? Forget the donut metaphor. That's for a different podcast. That's about stoicism and what

you're in control of. And you'll be surprised. You're in control of very little. One thing you're in control of

is what you do with the thought. So stop trying to change a thought Stop being annoyed with your mind

for the thought. Every thought your mind is coming up with is one you've subconsciously trained it to do already.

You

haven't consciously taken over. And I don't all the time. Don't get me wrong. Not every thought that arises, I,

oh, let's sit down and analyse it. I'm still going with the habit 99% of the day. But that 1%

changing is making all the difference. It really does. So

I never, no longer preach to people think positive. I don't tell people how to think. I invite people to

to respond to their thoughts I Hope that makes sense. If that helps. So

I said I would release a podcast this week, whether it's good or bad, but this is the podcast. Hopefully

you enjoyed it. Hopefully it will make a difference. Hopefully it will give you a different way of looking at

your mind. And let me know in the reviews and the comments um what you think of the podcast.

Let me know if, what kind of topics you'd like me to cover. Ask me questions

um Send an email to me, StevenWebb.uk. It's got all the links. So that take care. Have an amazing

month and I will see you next week. And remember, stop trying to change your thoughts but

you are in control of what you do with them. Love you and have a good one.

Weekly Calm

One calm email.
Every Sunday.

A little space to pause, a practical thought to take into the week, and a reminder that you’re not doing this alone.

Join and I will send you my book, 5 Simple Practices for Inner Peace. Free, and yours to keep.