We're All Terrible Meditators: The Art of Doing Nothing on Purpose
Are you bad at meditating? So is everyone. The mind wanders because that is its job. Meditation is not quieting it, it is noticing you have gone and coming back.
Are you bad at meditating? So is everyone. The mind wanders because that is its job. Meditation is not quieting it, it is noticing you have gone and coming back.
Support me with a coffee and join my Weekly Calm every Sunday: stevenwebb.uk
When I started, I thought meditation was sit down, be quiet, no thoughts, pure bliss. It lasted about 30 seconds. Then a teacher gave me the only instruction that ever worked: just sit and do nothing. His version had four letters. Your body knows how to breathe and your mind knows how to go quiet. The job is getting out of their way. Think of a snow globe. To settle the snow you do nothing, you just watch, and life will shake it up again anyway. Every time the mind wanders it is a happy accident, as Bob Ross would say. Smile, say thank you mind, and come back.
One thing to try: Get somewhere five minutes early and just sit in the car. Each time you catch the mind off in a story, smile, say thank you mind, and come back to what you can hear and feel. Five minutes, twice a day.
In this episode
(0:03) Winnie the Pooh, and why meditation is doing nothing on purpose
(1:19) The only instruction that ever worked: just sit and do nothing (his had four letters)
(2:22) The snow globe. To settle the snow, you do nothing
(3:45) You're being thought. What's your next thought going to be?
(4:23) We're all terrible meditators, and why that is fine
(5:47) Bob Ross and the happy accident
(9:24) 178 podcasts and I've yet to find the one little thing that fixes everything
(13:15) Calvin and Hobbes, do a bit more nothing, and five minutes in the car
With gratitude to
Jess, David, Angi, Jeroen, Jose and Jill, Helen, Tracey, Carol, Hayden, Sarafena, Cheryl and Strength from Within Yoga, and new monthly supporter Rowan
Support the podcast and join the Weekly Calm: stevenwebb.uk
Thank you for listening.
Steven
The question this answers
Why can't I quiet my mind when I meditate, and am I doing it wrong?
When I started, I thought meditation was sit down, be quiet, have peace, no thoughts, absolute bliss. It lasted less than a minute and I thought, yeah, stuff this. I only started because it was cool and trendy.
Then the breathing. The app says breathe in, and I have not finished breathing in yet. Now breathe out, and I already have, because I was hyperventilating. Even being told how to breathe never worked with me. I ended up lightheaded, or tired, or asleep.
What landed was my teacher saying just sit and do nothing. His actual words were four letters, and the last two stood for "up". It is that simple. My body knows how to breathe. My mind knows how to go quiet. My job is to get out of their way, again and again and again.
The heart of it
The mind wanders because that is what it evolved to do. You are not failing when it does.
You are being thought. Try it. What is your next thought going to be? You have no idea.
Meditation is not the quiet. It is noticing you have gone, and coming back.
I loved my snow globe as a child. When you want the snow to settle, what do you do? Nothing. You watch it. Keep shaking it, keep trying to make it fall a certain way, and it never settles. Life will shake it up again anyway.
We're all terrible meditators. We're all terrible at what we do.
If meditation means sitting there in peace and quiet and enjoying it, then yes, all of us are terrible. But it is not about that. It comes down to noticing the wandering. Ah, I have gone into a story. Sometimes you are five minutes into a party from twenty years ago, and what you should have said, before you notice. At that point you smile and say thank you, mind. It has done what it does. Bob Ross would call it a happy accident.
Here is the bit that matters. When the mind is off in story, it is cramming everything into this moment. The present you need to buy in two years. The thing you said wrong twenty years ago. Next week. The brain has no timeline. Years ago people came home from the fields, sat round the table, read a book, looked at the countryside. They knew how to do nothing. We are frightened of it now.
I have done 178 of these podcasts and I have yet to find the one little thing that sorts life out forever. I have got to the wisdom that it does not exist, and that is okay. What meditation does is smaller and better. It brings you back to this moment, where most of your problems are not actually here.
There's never enough time to do all the nothing you want.
Calvin, in Calvin and Hobbes
One small thing to try
Get somewhere five minutes early and sit in the car. Every time you find the mind doing something, bring it back and become witness to the breath. What can I hear? What can I feel? What is under my bum right now?
Notice your shoulders while you are there. Most of us hold them up all day, on guard, ready for the world. Let them drop.
Do that twice a day for five minutes, ten if you can. There is a meditation that goes with this one, Nothing to Get Right, and it barely says a word.
Questions people ask
My mind will not go quiet. Am I doing it wrong?
No. The mind has evolved to think, and if it finds a gap it fills it. You are not failing when it wanders. The practice is the catching, not the quiet. Catch it, smile, come back. That counts.
I can't follow the breathing instructions. What should I do?
Ignore them, honestly. Your body has breathed on its own your whole life. Sit, do nothing, and let it. If a teacher's count leaves you behind, you spend the next 30 seconds trying to catch up, and that is the opposite of the point.
Is a bath or a walk the same as meditating?
They are lovely and I recommend them, but no. Peace and quiet is a nice side effect. Meditation is noticing that the mind has gone into thought and the body has tensed, and stepping back from it. You can do that in a car park.
How long and how often?
Five minutes twice a day. Ten is better. You will have less hassle, you will be kinder, and people will drive you crazy a bit less.
Read along
The transcript
It follows the audio. Press any line to jump there.